One of Us Is Lying Summary

PART ONE : SIMON SAYS

Chapter 1

On Monday, September 24th, Simon Kelleher catches Bronwyn Rojas browsing the About That app, which he uses to spread gossip. In detention with Bronwyn, Addy, Cooper, and Nate, Simon begins taunting them about their social roles. The group is interrupted by a car crash outside, and Simon suddenly suffers an allergic reaction, collapsing in the classroom.

Despite frantic efforts to find an EpiPen, the group is unable to locate it in time. As Simon’s condition deteriorates, paramedics arrive to take over, but it’s too late. The severity of Simon's reaction marks a turning point for everyone involved.

Chapter 2

Cooper assists Addy in calling her boyfriend, Jake, who arrives to pick her up, while Ms. Grayson allows everyone to leave detention. Nate and Bronwyn, who have known each other since kindergarten, discuss the day’s chaotic events as Nate drives her home.

When they arrive at Bronwyn’s house, her phone rings with the devastating news that Simon has died. The sudden turn of events leaves them both in shock and uncertainty about what’s to come.

Chapter 3

The next morning, all attention is on Bronwyn as Mrs. Park announces Simon’s death and informs the students in detention that they must see a therapist. Bronwyn feels a sense of relief, believing her own secret remains hidden.

At school, Cooper and the others are interrogated by Officer Budapest about the detention. Cooper recalls seeing Simon getting water but notes nothing out of the ordinary. Later, while Keely checks on him, Cooper receives a mysterious text message, adding to the mounting tension.

Chapter 4

That night, Addy is preoccupied with a pimple and feels envious of her friend Keely’s beauty. Jake informs Addy that Simon’s mother wants him to be a pallbearer at Simon’s funeral. Despite her concerns, Addy, who is on birth control, continues to have sex with Jake whenever he wants.

Meanwhile, at Nate’s house, his father has already passed out from drinking. Nate, who deals drugs, receives a text about a Tumblr post taking responsibility for Simon’s death, which was attributed to a peanut allergy.

Chapter 5

On Friday night, while Bronwyn and her sister Maeve are watching Netflix, Nate unexpectedly shows up at their door. Although Bronwyn feels uncomfortable, she lets him in, and he compliments her piano playing.

Meanwhile, Officer Budapest interrogates Addy, who recalls visiting the nurse’s office for Tylenol. To her surprise, she sees Jake’s friend TJ in the back seat of Jake’s car. TJ reassures Addy that their secret remains safe and undisclosed.

Chapter 6

On Saturday afternoon, Cooper delivers an impressive game, catching the eye of a major-league scout. Later at Simon’s memorial service, he encounters Leah Jackson, who shows him a Tumblr post claiming responsibility for Simon’s death.

Meanwhile, Nate meets with his probation officer, Officer Lopez, who drives him to Simon’s funeral. Nate feels increasingly anxious amid the heavy police presence and becomes alarmed when one of the officers approaches him after the service.

Chapter 7

After Simon’s funeral, Addy is taken to the police station, where Detective Wheeler confronts her with unpublished posts from Simon’s app that accuse the detention students of various offenses. Pressured to confess, Addy maintains her innocence and calls her sister for assistance.

Meanwhile, Cooper is questioned by Detective Chang, who discloses Simon’s posts about steroid use. Cooper denies any involvement with the accusations and is advised by his father to stop speaking to the police without legal representation.

Chapter 8

Bronwyn’s parents refuse to allow Detective Mendoza to question her, but they are disturbed by Simon’s post accusing her of cheating. Overwhelmed by guilt, Bronwyn admits to her parents that the post is true, though she falsely claims there were no other issues with Simon.

Later, Officer Lopez warns Nate that if he’s caught dealing drugs, he could be implicated in Simon’s death. After tidying up at home, Nate goes to Bronwyn’s house to talk, but is turned away by her father.

Chapter 9

On Sunday evening, Addy visits her sister Ashton’s apartment to discuss the case and her affair with TJ. Despite her initial reluctance, Addy agrees to let Ashton drive her to see Jake.

When she confesses to Jake that the police believe her secret affair with TJ could be a motive for Simon’s murder, Jake reacts with anger and demands that Addy leave.

PART TWO: HIDE-AND-SEEK

Chapter 10

On Monday morning, Bronwyn meets with her attorney, Robin Stafford, who advises her to steer clear of the other suspects. At school, Bronwyn inquires about Nate’s recent visit, and he explains it was to apologize for a past prank.

Later, Cooper witnesses Jake punching TJ and confirms the truth of Simon’s post about Addy. Additionally, Cooper receives troubling news that his grandmother is in the hospital.

Chapter 11

That evening, Nate calls Bronwyn from the “burner” phone he gave her, and they discuss their past and Simon's death. Nate reassures Bronwyn about the cheating rumor and they talk about his innocence, offering each other some solace.

The next day, Addy is distressed to find “WHORE” scrawled on her locker and confronts TJ about their past. Despite the gossip, TJ offers to sit with her during lunch to provide support.

Chapter 12

On Thursday, Simon’s secrets about the suspects are posted online, accompanied by a challenge to identify his killer. Bronwyn and the other suspects are summoned to the office, but they refuse to speak about the case.

Later, Bronwyn and Nate talk about Simon’s behavior and potential suspects, continuing their movie nights from their separate homes as a way to stay connected.

Chapter 13

On Friday, Cooper visits his grandmother in the hospital, reassuring her that he’s not involved with steroids or Simon’s death. He feels a pang of guilt for not being entirely honest with her.

Later, Nate invites Bronwyn to watch a movie, but she declines. They continue their conversations over the phone, and Nate offers her a new burner phone when the old one runs out of minutes.

Chapter 14

Ashton suggests that Addy rent bikes for a change of pace, but Addy ends up in tears, overwhelmed by her sister’s failed marriage and her own secrets. She decides not to attend a party that Cooper invited her to, as Jake will be there.

Meanwhile, Bronwyn is disturbed to find Maeve hacking into Simon’s app, uncovering new rumors and an old file about Cooper. Maeve’s hacking raises concerns for Bronwyn, who begins to question Maeve’s intentions. At the party, Cooper faces teasing about being a suspect and discovers that a local newspaper article has named him and the others as persons of interest in Simon’s murder.

Chapter 15

On Monday, reporters swarm the school, prompting Nate and Bronwyn to attempt an escape through the woods. Tensions rise when Bronwyn suggests hiring a lawyer, leading Nate to walk away in frustration.

The following day, with the news vans gone, Addy tries to offer comfort to Janae, but Janae responds coldly. Addy then accepts an invitation from Bronwyn for lunch and later decides to cut her long hair at the salon.

Chapter 16

Bronwyn is upset while watching a TV special on Simon's murder, feeling distressed by the intense coverage. Meanwhile, Maeve uncovers troubling comments by Simon and attempts to decode a file related to Cooper.

In a separate development, Cooper breaks up with Keely after she confesses to kissing Nate, leading to a heated argument between them.

Chapter 17

Bronwyn is upset while watching a TV special on Simon's murder, feeling distressed by the intense coverage. Meanwhile, Maeve uncovers troubling comments by Simon and attempts to decode a file related to Cooper.

In a separate development, Cooper breaks up with Keely after she confesses to kissing Nate, leading to a heated argument between them.

Chapter 18

Bronwyn, puzzled by Nate’s mother’s sudden appearance, drives off with Maeve. At the police station, they find an old post from Simon mocking Maeve’s cancer battle and a death threat linked to an email address associated with Bronwyn.

Addy visits Jake, only to realize he’s not interested in rekindling their relationship, which leaves her feeling relieved and ready to move on. Meanwhile, to escape the media frenzy, Cooper visits Kris, and they share a kiss.

PART THREE: TRUTH OR DARE

Chapter 19

Nate is disturbed by his mother’s return and the lies he’s told about her in the past. At a party, a girl named Mallory accuses Bronwyn of murder, but Nate refuses drugs and feels relieved when Bronwyn calls him.

Later, Bronwyn sneaks Nate into her house so they can talk privately. Nate confesses his past lies about his mother, and they share a kiss, deciding to pursue a relationship despite the ongoing challenges.

Chapter 20

Cooper reflects on how his father's baseball ambitions fueled rumors about steroids and fears about being exposed by Simon. He regrets not being kinder to Simon and feels burdened by the negative attention.

Meanwhile, Nate, troubled by his mother's return, cuts their dinner short and avoids an interview with Mikhail Powers. He leaves his mother to handle the situation alone, adding to his sense of isolation.

Chapter 21

During lunch, Maeve plans to send Simon's old offensive posts to Mikhail Powers, leading to tension with Janae, who defends Simon's actions.

Later, Addy faces bullying in gym class but receives unexpected help from Janae, who invites her to hang out. When Janae leaves abruptly, Bronwyn cautions Addy not to trust her.

Chapter 22

Cooper is taken to the police station, where Detective Chang confronts him with a decrypted post from Simon about a left-handed pitcher, “CC,” rumored to be cheating on his girlfriend. The police have a warrant to search Cooper’s home, heightening his sense of pressure.

Feeling overwhelmed, Cooper decides to come out as gay to his family, admitting that Simon had discovered this secret but clarifies that it wasn’t related to steroids.

Chapter 23

The next morning, Cooper confides in Addy about Simon’s post and his fear of being a prime suspect, revealing he's gay. He worries that this new information might make him an even stronger suspect in Simon’s murder.

At lunch, Cooper endures bullying, but Nate steps in to defend him while Bronwyn creates a distraction with a passionate kiss. Addy is grateful that, unlike herself, Cooper has true support from his friend Luis during these challenging times.

Chapter 24

Nate and Bronwyn share a kiss at a construction site before joining Addy and Cooper to discuss Simon’s case and potential suspects. They are determined to piece together the clues and figure out what really happened.

The next evening, a TV special shifts public focus away from the Bayview Four, offering them a brief respite. However, the following morning, Maeve wakes Bronwyn to deliver the shocking news that Nate has been arrested for Simon’s murder.

Chapter 25

Bronwyn persuades Eli Kleinfelter to take Nate’s case by highlighting Nate’s troubled background and the urgent need for legal intervention. However, upon returning home, she is overwhelmed by the media frenzy surrounding Nate’s arrest.

Meanwhile, Cooper, shocked by the news of Nate’s arrest, deals with his father's disapproval. Despite his own reservations, Cooper agrees to assist Bronwyn by asking his friend Luis about the car crash, determined to help clear Nate’s name.

Chapter 26

At Eli’s office, Nate’s mother explains that Nate’s arrest followed an anonymous tip that led to incriminating items found in his locker and bedroom, though Nate’s fingerprints were not on them. Eli agrees to represent Nate but cautions Bronwyn that he cannot discuss the case further due to legal constraints.

Meanwhile, Addy declines TJ’s offer to study, and Bronwyn invites her and Cooper to assist in the investigation of Simon’s murder. They uncover a clue in the Tumblr posts that matches a lie Addy once told, adding a new twist to their search for the truth.

Chapter 27

Bronwyn sends the Tumblr post clue to Nate’s mother, who advises her to stay out of the investigation. Undeterred, Bronwyn, Cooper, and the rest of the group continue their inquiry and discover that Simon had paid Sam Barron a thousand dollars to stage the car crash.

Addy speculates that Jake’s jealousy over her friendship with Cooper might be a motive, but the link between Jake and the other suspects, including Nate and Bronwyn, remains ambiguous. The group is left grappling with the complex web of relationships and motives.

Chapter 28

At a coffee shop, Cooper introduces Kris to the group while they review Sam Barron’s confession and consider Jake’s potential involvement. Eli confirms that Barron admitted to staging the accident for Simon, leading Kris to suggest that Simon and Jake were the real perpetrators. The group debates the implications, with Addy distressed by the idea of Jake seeking revenge, prompting Ashton to take her home.

As Bronwyn and Maeve depart, Kris and Cooper share a moment of intimacy, kissing before leaving hand in hand. Meanwhile, Nate, grappling with his incarceration, resigns himself to the belief that Bronwyn is better off without him.

Chapter 29

The next evening, Addy realizes that Jake might have planted a phone in her backpack and learns that Janae has been absent from school. Visiting Janae, Addy and Cooper discover Simon’s manifesto, which details Simon’s plan to frame Bronwyn, Nate, Cooper, and Addy for his murder.

As Addy hides and records Jake confronting Janae, Jake becomes violent. He attacks Addy, but Cooper arrives just in time to intervene, saving her and calling for an ambulance.

Chapter 30

Nate is released from custody, deeply grateful to Bronwyn and the “murder club” for their support, but he feels that a future with her is unlikely. Meanwhile, Cooper is grappling with Jake’s betrayal and apologizes to Keely, hoping for better acceptance of his relationship with Kris.

Addy is recovering from her concussion and looks forward to a fresh start with her sister Ashton. As Bronwyn prepares for Yale, she reflects on her past mistakes and regrets, while Nate, despite thanking her, believes it’s best for them to move on separately.

PART ONE : SIMON SAYS

Chapter 1

On Monday, September 24th, Simon Kelleher catches Bronwyn Rojas looking at the About That app, which he uses to spread gossip. In detention with Bronwyn, Addy, Cooper, and Nate, Simon starts teasing them about their social roles. After a car crash outside, Simon suddenly has an allergic reaction and collapses. Despite the group's efforts to find an EpiPen, they can't locate it in time, and paramedics arrive as Simon's condition worsens.

Chapter 2

Cooper helps Addy call her boyfriend, Jake, who picks her up, and Ms. Grayson allows everyone to leave. Nate and Bronwyn, who have known each other since kindergarten, talk about the day's events while Nate gives her a ride home. As they arrive at Bronwyn’s house, her phone rings with the news that Simon has died.

Chapter 3

The next morning, all eyes are on Bronwyn as Mrs. Park announces Simon’s death and says that everyone who was in detention will need to see a therapist. Bronwyn is relieved that her secret seems safe. At school, Cooper and the others are questioned by Officer Budapest about the detention, and Cooper remembers seeing Simon get water but nothing unusual happening. Later, Cooper receives a mysterious text message while Keely checks on him.

Chapter 4

That night, Addy is worried about a pimple and feels jealous of her friend Keely’s beauty. Jake tells Addy that Simon’s mother wants him to be a pallbearer at Simon’s funeral. Addy, who is on birth control, has sex with Jake whenever he wants. At Nate’s house, his father is already passed out, and Nate, who sells drugs, gets a text about a Tumblr post claiming responsibility for Simon’s death, which was caused by a peanut allergy.

Chapter 5

On Friday night, while Bronwyn and her sister Maeve are watching Netflix, Nate unexpectedly visits them. Bronwyn is uncomfortable but lets him in, and he praises her piano playing. Meanwhile, Officer Budapest questions Addy, who remembers she visited the nurse’s office for Tylenol. Addy is surprised to see Jake’s friend TJ in the back seat of Jake’s car and is reassured by TJ that no one knows about her secret with him.

Chapter 6

On Saturday afternoon, Cooper pitches a great game, impressing a major-league scout. At Simon’s memorial service later, he sees Leah Jackson, who was affected by Simon’s actions, and she shows him a Tumblr post claiming responsibility for Simon’s death. Meanwhile, Nate meets his probation officer, Officer Lopez, who drives him to Simon’s funeral. Nate feels trapped by the police presence there and is worried when one of the officers approaches him after the service.

Chapter 7

After Simon’s funeral, Addy is taken to the police station where Detective Wheeler shows her unpublished posts from Simon’s app that accuse the detention students of various wrongdoings. Detective Wheeler pressures Addy to confess, but she insists she’s innocent and calls her sister for help. Meanwhile, Cooper is questioned by Detective Chang, who reveals Simon’s posts about steroid use. Cooper denies any collaboration with the others and is advised by his father to stop talking to the police without a lawyer.

Chapter 8

Bronwyn’s parents refuse to let Detective Mendoza question her but are troubled by Simon’s post about her cheating. Bronwyn, feeling guilty, admits the post is true but lies about having no other issues with Simon. Later, Officer Lopez warns Nate that if he’s caught dealing drugs, he could be blamed for Simon’s death. Nate, after cleaning up at home, goes to Bronwyn’s house to talk, but is turned away by her father.

Chapter 9

On Sunday evening, Addy goes to her sister Ashton’s apartment to talk about the case and her affair with TJ. Despite resisting, Addy agrees to let Ashton drive her to see Jake. She confesses to Jake that the police think she had a motive to kill Simon because of her secret affair with TJ. Jake is furious and asks Addy to leave.

PART TWO: HIDE-AND-SEEK

Chapter 10

On Monday morning, Bronwyn meets with her attorney, Robin Stafford, who advises her to avoid the other suspects. At school, Bronwyn asks Nate why he visited her, and he explains he wanted to apologize for a past prank. Later, Cooper sees Jake punch TJ and realizes Simon’s post about Addy was true. Cooper also learns his grandmother is in the hospital.

Chapter 11

That evening, Nate calls Bronwyn from the “burner” phone he gave her, and they talk about their past and Simon's death. Nate reassures Bronwyn about her cheating rumor, and they discuss his innocence. The next day, Addy is upset to find “WHORE” written on her locker and questions TJ about their past. TJ offers to sit with her during lunch despite the gossip.

Chapter 12

On Thursday, Simon’s secrets about the suspects are posted online with a challenge to find his killer. Bronwyn and the other suspects are called to the office, where they refuse to talk. Later, Bronwyn and Nate discuss Simon’s behavior and possible suspects, and they continue their movie nights from their own homes.

Chapter 13

On Friday, Cooper visits his grandmother in the hospital, assuring her that he didn’t take steroids or have anything to do with Simon’s death. He feels guilty for not being honest with her. Later, Nate invites Bronwyn over to watch a movie, but she declines. They continue talking on the phone, and Nate offers her a new burner phone when the old one runs out of minutes.

Chapter 14

Ashton suggests Addy rent bikes to have some fun, but Addy ends up crying about her sister’s failed marriage and her own secrets. Addy decides not to go to a party Cooper invites her to because Jake will be there.

Bronwyn is upset to find Maeve hacking into Simon’s app, discovering new rumors and an old file about Cooper. Maeve’s hacking skills worry Bronwyn, who starts to question Maeve’s motives. At the party, Cooper is teased about being a suspect and learns that an article in the local paper names him and the others as people of interest in Simon’s murder.

Chapter 15

On Monday, reporters swarm the school, and Nate and Bronwyn try to leave through the woods. Nate gets upset when Bronwyn suggests hiring a lawyer, and he walks off after a tense moment.

The next day, with the news vans gone, Addy tries to comfort Janae, who reacts coldly. Addy then accepts Bronwyn’s lunch invitation and later decides to cut her long hair at the salon.

Chapter 16

Bronwyn watches a TV special on Simon's murder and is distressed by the coverage. Maeve finds troubling comments by Simon and tries to decode a file about Cooper. Cooper breaks up with Keely, who reveals she kissed Nate, leading to a heated argument.

Chapter 17

In science class, Addy partners with TJ, who tells her he likes her more when she's not with Jake. After class, Jake and Addy agree to talk later. Bronwyn and Nate discuss a lawyer who will investigate Simon’s death and possible suspects, but Nate is annoyed by Bronwyn’s theories. They are interrupted when Bronwyn is called for more police questioning, and Nate is surprised to find his mother, who he claimed was dead, at his home.

Chapter 18

Bronwyn, confused by Nate’s mother’s unexpected appearance, drives off with Maeve. At the police station, they discover an old post from Simon mocking Maeve’s cancer battle and a death threat from an email linked to Bronwyn. Addy visits Jake, realizes he’s not interested in making up, and feels relieved to move on. Cooper, escaping media pressure, visits Kris and they share a kiss.

PART THREE: TRUTH OR DARE

Chapter 19

Nate is troubled by his mother’s return and his past lies about her. At a party, a girl named Mallory accuses Bronwyn of murder, but Nate declines drugs and is relieved when Bronwyn calls. Later, Bronwyn sneaks Nate into her house to talk. Nate explains his lie about his mother, and they share a kiss, deciding to explore a relationship despite challenges.

Chapter 20

Cooper reflects on how his father’s baseball plan led to rumors about steroids and fears of being outed by Simon. He regrets being unkind to Simon. Meanwhile, Nate, uncomfortable with his mother’s return, leaves their dinner early and avoids an interview with Mikhail Powers, leaving his mother to handle the situation alone.

Chapter 21

During lunch, Maeve plans to send Simon's old offensive posts to Mikhail Powers, causing tension with Janae, who defends Simon. Later, Addy is bullied in gym class, but Janae helps her clean up and unexpectedly invites her to hang out. After Janae leaves suddenly, Bronwyn warns Addy not to trust her.

Chapter 22

Cooper is brought to the police station where Detective Chang confronts him with Simon’s decrypted post about a left-handed pitcher, “CC,” rumored to be cheating on his girlfriend. While the police have a warrant to search his home, Cooper, feeling the pressure, comes out as gay to his family, revealing that Simon discovered his secret, but it wasn’t related to steroids.

Chapter 23

The next morning, Cooper confides in Addy about Simon’s post and his fear of being a prime suspect, revealing he's gay. At lunch, Cooper faces bullying, but Nate steps in, and Bronwyn distracts everyone with a passionate kiss. Addy appreciates that, unlike her, Cooper has genuine support from his friend Luis during this tough time.

Chapter 24

Nate and Bronwyn share a kiss at a construction site before meeting Addy and Cooper to discuss Simon’s case and possible suspects. The next evening, a TV special shifts public scrutiny away from the Bayview Four, but the following morning, Maeve wakes Bronwyn to reveal that Nate has been arrested for Simon’s murder.

Chapter 25

Bronwyn convinces Eli Kleinfelter to take Nate’s case, citing Nate’s troubled background, but is met with media frenzy upon returning home. Cooper, stunned by the news of Nate’s arrest, faces his father's disapproval but agrees to help Bronwyn by asking Luis about the car crash, despite his reluctance to pursue the lead.

Chapter 26

At Eli’s office, Nate’s mother reveals that Nate’s arrest stemmed from an anonymous tip that led to incriminating items in his locker and bedroom, though Nate’s fingerprints were absent. Eli agrees to take on Nate’s case but warns Bronwyn he can’t discuss it further. Meanwhile, Addy rejects TJ’s offer to study, and Bronwyn invites her and Cooper to help investigate Simon’s murder. They discover a clue in the Tumblr posts that matches a lie Addy told.

Chapter 27

Bronwyn sends the Tumblr post clue to Nate’s mother, who advises her to stay out of it. The group, including Cooper, investigates and learns that Simon paid Sam Barron a thousand dollars to stage the car crash. Addy wonders if Jake’s jealousy of her friendship with Cooper could be a motive, but the connection to Nate and Bronwyn remains unclear.

Chapter 28

At a coffee shop, Cooper introduces Kris to the group as they discuss Sam Barron’s confession and Jake’s possible involvement. Eli confirms that Barron admitted staging the accident for Simon, and Kris suggests that Simon and Jake were the real culprits. As Addy is upset by the suggestion that Jake sought revenge, Ashton takes her home, and Bronwyn and Maeve leave, allowing Kris and Cooper to share a kiss before leaving hand in hand. Meanwhile, Nate struggles with his situation in jail, believing Bronwyn is better off without him.

Chapter 29

The next evening, Addy recalls that Jake could have planted a phone in her backpack and discovers that Janae has been missing from school. When Addy and Cooper visit Janae, she reveals Simon’s manifesto, showing Simon’s plan to frame Bronwyn, Nate, Cooper, and Addy. As Addy hides and records Jake confronting Janae, Jake attacks her, but Cooper arrives in time to save her and call for an ambulance.

Chapter 30

Nate is released from custody, overwhelmed with gratitude for Bronwyn and the “murder club,” though he feels a future with her is impossible. As Cooper struggles to understand Jake’s betrayal, he apologizes to Keely and hopes for better acceptance of Kris. Addy recovers from her concussion and plans a fresh start with her sister Ashton. Bronwyn, preparing for Yale, regrets her past mistakes, and though Nate thanks her, he feels their lives should move on separately.

PART ONE : SIMON SAYS

Chapter 1

On Monday, September 24th, Simon Kelleher catches Bronwyn Rojas browsing the About That app, a platform he uses to spread malicious gossip. During detention, Simon begins taunting Bronwyn, Addy, Cooper, and Nate about their social roles and secrets. His provocations create a tense atmosphere among the group, each of them feeling the sting of his words.

The situation escalates when a car crash outside the classroom distracts everyone. Simon, who is already agitated, suddenly suffers an allergic reaction and collapses. The group scrambles to find an EpiPen, but despite their frantic search, they are unable to locate it in time.

As Simon's condition rapidly deteriorates, paramedics arrive, but their efforts to revive him come too late. Simon’s death marks a profound turning point for the group, whose lives are now irrevocably changed by the tragic event.

Chapter 2

Cooper helps Addy call her boyfriend, Jake, who quickly arrives to pick her up as Ms. Grayson dismisses everyone from detention. The chaotic events of the day leave everyone shaken, and Nate offers to drive Bronwyn home. As they drive through the quiet streets, Nate and Bronwyn reflect on the day's disturbing events and try to make sense of the turmoil surrounding them.

Upon arriving at Bronwyn’s house, the pair is greeted by the ringing of her phone. The news on the other end is devastating: Simon has died. The gravity of the situation hits hard, and both Nate and Bronwyn are left grappling with shock and confusion.

The sudden and tragic turn of events casts a heavy shadow over their lives. As they stand on the brink of this new reality, both Nate and Bronwyn face an uncertain future, uncertain of how the day's events will reshape their lives and relationships.

Chapter 3

The following morning, Bronwyn becomes the center of attention as Mrs. Park announces Simon’s death to the students. She informs those in detention that they are required to see a therapist, causing a ripple of concern among the students. Despite the gravity of the situation, Bronwyn feels a fleeting sense of relief, convinced that her own secret remains safely concealed.

At school, Officer Budapest questions Cooper and the others about the events in detention. Cooper recalls seeing Simon getting water but insists nothing seemed unusual. The interrogation leaves him feeling uneasy, especially as the police scrutiny intensifies.

Later, as Cooper is checked on by his girlfriend Keely, he receives a mysterious text message that only heightens his anxiety. The unexpected message adds another layer of tension to an already stressful situation, making Cooper increasingly anxious about what’s to come.

Chapter 4

That night, Addy is fixated on a pimple and struggles with envy over her friend Keely’s beauty. Her worries are compounded when Jake informs her that Simon’s mother wants him to be a pallbearer at Simon’s funeral. Despite these mounting concerns, Addy, who is on birth control, continues her physical relationship with Jake, trying to maintain some normalcy amid the turmoil.

Meanwhile, at Nate’s house, his father has passed out from drinking, leaving Nate alone to navigate his own problems. As Nate, who deals drugs, sifts through the chaos of his life, he receives a troubling text message about a Tumblr post claiming responsibility for Simon’s death. The post attributes the fatality to a peanut allergy, adding to the already intense and confusing situation Nate finds himself in.

The night is filled with a sense of unease and uncertainty for both Addy and Nate. While Addy tries to manage her personal insecurities and complex relationship with Jake, Nate grapples with the implications of the Tumblr post and his tumultuous home environment, deepening the overall tension of the unfolding events.

Chapter 5

On Friday night, Bronwyn and her sister Maeve are enjoying a quiet evening watching Netflix when Nate unexpectedly arrives at their door. Despite feeling uneasy about the surprise visit, Bronwyn decides to let him in. Nate, trying to ease the tension, compliments her piano playing, leading to an awkward yet heartfelt moment between them.

Meanwhile, Officer Budapest is questioning Addy at the police station. During her interrogation, Addy recalls a visit to the nurse’s office for Tylenol, trying to piece together the events of that day. Her concern is momentarily eased when she unexpectedly spots Jake’s friend TJ in the back seat of Jake’s car. TJ reassures Addy that their secret remains safe and undisclosed, offering a brief sense of relief amid the escalating drama.

As the night progresses, both Bronwyn and Addy are left navigating their own complex situations. Bronwyn deals with Nate’s unanticipated visit and the emotional undercurrents it brings, while Addy finds a small comfort in TJ’s promise, even as the pressure of the ongoing investigation looms large.

Chapter 6

On Saturday afternoon, Cooper puts on a stellar performance at his baseball game, drawing the attention of a major-league scout. This boost in his athletic career momentarily lifts his spirits, offering a bright spot amid the turmoil surrounding Simon's death.

Later that day, at Simon’s memorial service, Cooper encounters Leah Jackson, who has been deeply affected by Simon's actions. Leah shares a Tumblr post with Cooper that takes responsibility for Simon’s death, intensifying the mystery and suspicion that has been plaguing the group.

Meanwhile, Nate has an uneasy meeting with his probation officer, Officer Lopez, who drives him to Simon’s funeral. Surrounded by a heavy police presence, Nate’s anxiety escalates, culminating in alarm when an officer approaches him after the service. The interaction leaves Nate feeling increasingly trapped and concerned about his future.

Chapter 7

After Simon’s funeral, Addy is taken to the police station, where Detective Wheeler confronts her with unpublished posts from Simon’s app accusing the students from detention of various offenses. Under pressure to confess, Addy firmly maintains her innocence and calls her sister for support, feeling increasingly overwhelmed by the situation.

Simultaneously, Cooper faces questioning from Detective Chang, who reveals Simon’s posts about steroid use. Although Cooper denies any involvement with the accusations, the mounting scrutiny from the police adds to his distress. Cooper’s father advises him to cease talking to the police without a lawyer present, underscoring the seriousness of the situation.

As the investigation intensifies, both Addy and Cooper grapple with the weight of Simon’s accusations and the growing pressure from law enforcement. Their situations become more complex, leading them to seek out legal guidance and emotional support from their families.

Chapter 8

Bronwyn’s parents refuse to let Detective Mendoza question her, but they are deeply troubled by Simon’s post accusing her of cheating. Overwhelmed by guilt, Bronwyn admits to her parents that the post is accurate, though she falsely claims there were no additional issues with Simon. Her confession only adds to the mounting tension within her family.

Meanwhile, Officer Lopez warns Nate that if he’s caught dealing drugs, he could be implicated in Simon’s death, intensifying Nate’s anxiety. After a tense conversation, Nate returns home and decides to clean up his living space in an attempt to regain some control over his chaotic situation.

Determined to seek support, Nate goes to Bronwyn’s house to talk things over. However, despite his efforts to explain, Bronwyn’s father turns him away, leaving Nate feeling even more isolated and desperate. The complexities of their situation continue to strain their relationships as they navigate the unfolding crisis.

Chapter 9

On Sunday evening, Addy visits her sister Ashton’s apartment to talk about the ongoing investigation and her affair with TJ. Although hesitant at first, Addy eventually agrees to let Ashton drive her to see Jake, hoping for some resolution.

When Addy arrives at Jake’s place, she nervously confesses that the police suspect her secret affair with TJ might have been a motive for Simon’s murder. Jake's reaction is one of intense anger, as he struggles with the implications of her revelation.

In a heated exchange, Jake demands that Addy leave, unable to process the accusations and feeling betrayed by her admission. The confrontation leaves Addy feeling distressed and unsure of what to do next, deepening her sense of isolation.

PART TWO: HIDE-AND-SEEK

Chapter 10

On Monday morning, Bronwyn meets with her attorney, Robin Stafford, who advises her to avoid any contact with the other suspects to protect her legal standing. This advice leaves Bronwyn feeling more isolated as she navigates the aftermath of Simon's death.

At school, Bronwyn asks Nate about his recent visit, and he explains that he came by to apologize for a prank from their past. Their conversation is awkward but reveals Nate’s attempt to mend fences and offer some semblance of normalcy amidst the chaos.

Later that day, Cooper witnesses a heated altercation between Jake and TJ, culminating in Jake punching TJ. This confirms the truth of Simon’s post about Addy, adding to Cooper’s mounting concerns. To further complicate matters, Cooper receives distressing news that his grandmother is in the hospital, compounding his emotional strain.

Chapter 11

That evening, Nate uses the "burner" phone he gave Bronwyn to call her, and they have a heartfelt conversation about their past and the events surrounding Simon's death. Nate reassures Bronwyn about the cheating rumor and discusses his innocence, providing both of them with a sense of relief amidst the turmoil.

The following day, Addy is deeply troubled when she discovers "WHORE" written on her locker, a cruel reminder of the ongoing gossip. She confronts TJ about their past, seeking answers and clarity amid the chaos.

Despite the public scandal and the hostility Addy faces, TJ offers to support her by sitting with her during lunch. His gesture of solidarity provides Addy with some much-needed comfort and companionship in a difficult time.

Chapter 12

On Thursday, Simon’s hidden posts about the suspects are published online, alongside a provocative challenge to uncover his killer. The posts stir up renewed scrutiny and tension as Bronwyn and the other suspects are called to the office. Despite the mounting pressure, they choose to remain silent about the case.

Later, Bronwyn and Nate discuss Simon's erratic behavior and possible suspects, trying to make sense of the chaos. They continue their movie nights, maintaining a sense of normalcy and connection despite the overwhelming circumstances.

These shared moments of normalcy provide a small comfort as they navigate their strained circumstances. The continued interaction serves as a refuge for both, helping them cope with the unfolding drama and their own personal struggles.

Chapter 13

On Friday, Cooper visits his grandmother in the hospital, attempting to ease her worries by assuring her that he is not involved with steroids or Simon’s death. Despite his reassurances, he grapples with a lingering sense of guilt for not being completely honest with her about the situation.

Later in the day, Nate invites Bronwyn to watch a movie, but she declines the offer. Instead, they maintain their connection through phone conversations, providing each other with support during this turbulent time.

As their old burner phone runs out of minutes, Nate offers Bronwyn a new one, ensuring they can continue their communication uninterrupted. Their ongoing dialogue remains a crucial source of comfort and reassurance amidst the growing tension and uncertainty.

Chapter 14

Ashton suggests that Addy rent bikes for a change of pace, but the outing only leads Addy to break down in tears, overwhelmed by her sister’s failed marriage and her own personal struggles. Feeling emotionally drained, Addy decides against attending the party Cooper invited her to, particularly because she doesn’t want to face Jake there.

Meanwhile, Bronwyn becomes alarmed when she finds Maeve hacking into Simon’s app. Maeve uncovers new rumors and an old file about Cooper, raising concerns for Bronwyn about Maeve’s intentions and motivations. The intrusion into Simon’s digital world makes Bronwyn question the trustworthiness of those around her.

At the party, Cooper endures teasing and unwelcome attention regarding his status as a suspect. He learns from a local newspaper article that he and the other students have been named as persons of interest in Simon’s murder, adding to the mounting pressure and scrutiny he faces.

Chapter 15

On Monday, the school is overwhelmed by reporters, prompting Nate and Bronwyn to try and escape through the woods to avoid the media frenzy. The situation escalates when Bronwyn suggests hiring a lawyer to help navigate the mounting legal troubles, causing Nate to walk away in frustration, feeling that her suggestion complicates matters further.

The next day, with the news vans finally gone, Addy attempts to comfort Janae, who reacts with noticeable coldness and distance. Feeling rebuffed, Addy accepts an invitation from Bronwyn to have lunch together, seeking solace and support from her friend.

Later, Addy decides to make a significant change and cuts her long hair at the salon, symbolizing a desire for a fresh start amidst the ongoing turmoil.

Chapter 16

Bronwyn feels increasingly distressed as she watches a TV special about Simon's murder, overwhelmed by the sensationalist coverage and the scrutiny it places on her and the other suspects. The relentless media focus exacerbates her anxiety and sense of isolation.

Meanwhile, Maeve dives into Simon’s old posts and uncovers disturbing comments, including a file related to Cooper that she tries to decode. Maeve's efforts reveal new layers to the case, intensifying Bronwyn’s concern about the hidden motives and potential implications.

In another development, Cooper confronts Keely after discovering she kissed Nate. The revelation leads to a heated argument, culminating in Cooper ending their relationship. The fallout from their confrontation adds to Cooper’s mounting stress and confusion.

Chapter 17

Bronwyn is deeply unsettled as she watches a TV special on Simon's murder, feeling overwhelmed by the relentless and invasive coverage that magnifies her distress and anxiety. The intense media scrutiny only heightens her sense of vulnerability and isolation.

While Bronwyn struggles with the media frenzy, Maeve delves into Simon’s old posts and discovers disturbing comments about Cooper. She begins to decode a file connected to Cooper, which reveals troubling information and adds new layers of complexity to the investigation.

Amidst the turmoil, Cooper confronts Keely after learning she kissed Nate. Their confrontation escalates into a heated argument, ultimately leading to Cooper ending their relationship. This personal crisis compounds Cooper’s stress, leaving him grappling with both his emotional and legal troubles.

Chapter 18

Bronwyn, taken aback by her sudden appearance, drives off with Maeve to the police station. There, they discover an old post from Simon that mocks Maeve's battle with cancer, as well as a death threat linked to an email address associated with Bronwyn. The disturbing findings add new layers to the mystery and raise troubling questions.

Addy decides to visit Jake, hoping for some resolution, but is confronted with his disinterest in rekindling their relationship. Although the encounter is emotionally charged, Addy feels a sense of relief and clarity, allowing her to move forward and leave the past behind.

Meanwhile, to escape the relentless media scrutiny, Cooper seeks solace with Kris. Their shared moment of intimacy provides a brief respite from the chaos, and they share a kiss, finding comfort in each other amidst the turmoil surrounding them.

PART THREE: TRUTH OR DARE

Chapter 19

Nate is deeply unsettled by his mother’s unexpected return, which forces him to confront the lies he has told about her. At a party that night, a girl named Mallory accuses Bronwyn of murder, adding to the chaos. Nate, rejecting offers of drugs and feeling overwhelmed, finds a moment of relief when Bronwyn calls him.

Later, Bronwyn sneaks Nate into her house for a private conversation. In their secluded space, Nate opens up about the dishonesty surrounding his mother and expresses his feelings. As they talk through their struggles and past mistakes, they share a heartfelt kiss.

Deciding to face their challenges together, Nate and Bronwyn agree to pursue their relationship despite the ongoing pressures and uncertainties. Their connection offers them both a glimmer of hope amid the turmoil that surrounds them.

Chapter 20

Cooper reflects on the intense pressure his father’s baseball ambitions placed on him, which fueled Simon’s rumors about steroid use. He grapples with feelings of regret for not being kinder to Simon, and the burden of the negative attention weighs heavily on him.

Meanwhile, Nate struggles with the emotional turmoil brought on by his mother’s return, feeling overwhelmed by the resurfacing lies and complications in his life. During a dinner with her, Nate decides to cut the evening short and skips an important interview with Mikhail Powers.

This decision leaves Nate feeling increasingly isolated as he leaves his mother to manage the situation alone. The combined weight of these challenges deepens his sense of disconnection from those around him.

Chapter 21

During lunch, Maeve decides to send Simon's offensive posts to Mikhail Powers, creating tension with Janae, who staunchly defends Simon's actions despite their damaging nature. Janae's defense of Simon further strains her relationship with Maeve.

Later, Addy encounters bullying in gym class, but Janae unexpectedly comes to her aid, offering to hang out afterward. This act of kindness seems to provide Addy with some relief from her recent struggles.

However, when Janae leaves abruptly, Bronwyn warns Addy about Janae's true intentions, advising her not to fully trust Janae despite the recent gesture of support. This advice leaves Addy feeling uncertain about where her trust should lie.

Chapter 22

Cooper is brought to the police station, where Detective Chang presents him with a decrypted post from Simon about a left-handed pitcher, “CC,” allegedly cheating on his girlfriend. This revelation intensifies Cooper’s anxiety, especially with the police now having a warrant to search his home.

Overwhelmed by the mounting pressure, Cooper makes a significant decision to come out as gay to his family. He reveals that Simon had discovered his sexual orientation but assures them that it was not connected to the steroid rumors.

This moment of vulnerability is accompanied by a sense of relief for Cooper, as he clears the air about his secret while grappling with the ongoing investigation and the scrutiny of Simon’s accusations.

Chapter 23

The next morning, Cooper opens up to Addy about Simon’s post and his escalating fear of being a prime suspect. He reveals that he is gay and worries that this new personal detail might further incriminate him in the murder investigation.

During lunch, Cooper faces harsh bullying, but Nate steps in to stand up for him. Meanwhile, Bronwyn provides a distraction with a passionate kiss, shifting the focus away from Cooper’s distress.

Addy reflects on Cooper's situation and appreciates the genuine support he receives from his friend Luis. She contrasts this with her own lack of support and feels a mix of gratitude and sadness, recognizing how much harder her own challenges have been.

Chapter 24

Nate and Bronwyn share a heartfelt kiss at a construction site before meeting up with Addy and Cooper to delve into Simon's case. Together, they discuss their theories and potential suspects, driven by a shared determination to uncover the truth behind Simon’s death.

The next evening, a TV special shifts public attention away from the Bayview Four, providing them with a much-needed break from the relentless scrutiny. This brief respite allows them to regroup and refocus on their investigation.

However, the following morning, Maeve delivers shocking news to Bronwyn: Nate has been arrested for Simon’s murder. The unexpected development leaves Bronwyn and the others reeling, adding a new layer of complexity to their already tangled situation.

Chapter 25

Bronwyn successfully convinces Eli Kleinfelter to take on Nate’s case by emphasizing the gravity of Nate’s situation and his troubled background, underscoring the urgent need for legal representation. Despite this victory, Bronwyn is soon engulfed by the media frenzy surrounding Nate's arrest, which escalates the stress and scrutiny on her and her friends.

Meanwhile, Cooper is stunned by the news of Nate’s arrest and faces backlash from his father, who disapproves of his involvement. Despite feeling uncertain and pressured, Cooper decides to help Bronwyn by reaching out to his friend Luis for information about the car crash, driven by a sense of loyalty and determination to assist Nate.

As Cooper navigates his strained family dynamics and the growing media circus, he remains focused on uncovering the truth. His commitment to helping Bronwyn and Nate underscores his resolve to stand by his friends during this tumultuous time.

Chapter 26

At Eli’s office, Nate’s mother reveals that Nate’s arrest stemmed from an anonymous tip which led to incriminating evidence found in his locker and bedroom. Despite Nate’s fingerprints being absent from the evidence, the situation remains dire. Eli agrees to take on Nate’s case but warns Bronwyn that he cannot discuss details due to legal constraints, leaving them with limited information.

Meanwhile, Addy turns down TJ’s offer to study, reflecting her growing concerns and isolation. Bronwyn seizes the opportunity to rally Addy and Cooper to help with Simon’s murder investigation. Together, they delve into the Tumblr posts linked to Simon and discover a clue that connects to a lie Addy had previously told, complicating their search for the truth.

The new revelation adds urgency to their investigation, intensifying the pressure on the group to piece together the puzzle. As they navigate this complex web of deceit and hidden motives, Bronwyn, Addy, and Cooper remain determined to uncover the real story behind Simon’s death.

Chapter 27

Bronwyn sends the clue from the Tumblr posts to Nate’s mother, hoping it might shed light on the case. However, she is advised to stay out of the investigation to avoid further complications. Despite this warning, Bronwyn, Cooper, and the rest of the group press on with their inquiry, determined to uncover the truth.

Their persistence pays off when they discover that Simon had paid Sam Barron a thousand dollars to stage the car crash, a revelation that deepens the mystery. This new piece of evidence suggests that Simon was manipulating the situation for his own gain, but it raises more questions about the extent of his plans.

Addy speculates that Jake’s jealousy over her friendship with Cooper could be a potential motive for Simon's machinations, but the connection between Jake and the other suspects, including Nate and Bronwyn, remains unclear. The group is left grappling with a tangled web of relationships and motives, struggling to piece together how all the elements fit into the larger puzzle of Simon’s death.

Chapter 28

At a coffee shop, Cooper introduces Kris to the group as they discuss Sam Barron’s confession and the possibility of Jake’s involvement. Eli confirms that Barron admitted to staging the car crash on Simon’s behalf, deepening the investigation. Kris suggests that Simon and Jake might have been the real masterminds behind the scheme, which sparks a heated debate among the group about the implications of this theory.

Addy is particularly troubled by the suggestion that Jake could have sought revenge, leading to an emotional reaction. Ashton, concerned for Addy’s well-being, decides to take her home to offer support. Meanwhile, as Bronwyn and Maeve leave, Kris and Cooper share a private moment, kissing before departing hand in hand, finding solace in each other amidst the turmoil.

Nate, still reeling from his incarceration, struggles with his situation and comes to a painful realization. He resigns himself to the belief that Bronwyn is better off without him, adding to his sense of isolation and despair as he faces the harsh reality of his circumstances.

Chapter 29

The next evening, Addy suspects that Jake may have planted a phone in her backpack and notices Janae's unexplained absence from school. Concerned, Addy and Cooper visit Janae's home, where they discover Simon’s manifesto. The document reveals Simon’s scheme to frame Bronwyn, Nate, Cooper, and Addy for his murder, intensifying their sense of urgency.

As Addy hides and records Jake confronting Janae, she captures the escalating confrontation on her phone. Jake's anger boils over, and he becomes physically aggressive, attacking Addy in a violent outburst.

Just in time, Cooper arrives at the scene and intervenes, rescuing Addy from Jake's assault. He immediately calls for an ambulance, ensuring Addy receives the help she needs and preventing further harm.

Chapter 30

Nate is released from custody, overwhelmed with gratitude towards Bronwyn and the rest of the “murder club” for their unwavering support. Despite his relief and appreciation, he feels that a future with Bronwyn is improbable due to the complexities of their situation.

Meanwhile, Cooper is left reeling from Jake’s betrayal and attempts to make amends with Keely, hoping for a better understanding of his relationship with Kris. He navigates the fallout from the recent events and works towards reconciling his personal struggles with the public scrutiny he faces.

As Addy recovers from her concussion, she looks forward to starting anew with her sister Ashton, eager to move past the tumultuous events. Bronwyn, preparing for her future at Yale, reflects on her past mistakes and regrets, feeling a deep sense of loss. Despite Nate’s gratitude, he believes it’s best for both of them to move on separately, signaling a poignant end to their shared journey.